• Home
  • About
  • START HERE
  • Hire Us
  • Book Coaching
  • Books
  • Speaking
  • Contact
  • Subscribe

Write & Publish Like a Pro

Your Toolkit for Excellence from Belinda Pollard & Small Blue Dog Publishing

  • Writing Tips
  • Write Your Life
  • Feedback & Revision
  • Self-Publishing
  • Book Marketing
You are here: Home / Beta Readers / Briefing a Beta Reader: Practical details

Briefing a Beta Reader: Practical details

By Belinda Pollard 15 Comments

Beta readers are those wonderful people (often volunteers) who read and critique the manuscripts of our books. Chosen carefully, briefed effectively and “heard” with discernment, I regard them as the superheroes of self-publishing. They can provide forms of editing – especially in the developmental stages of a book – that many self-publishers miss out on.

Traditionally-published writers need beta readers, too. You’ll find that most successful authors have at least one and often a team of them, whether they are other writers, editors, or trusted advisors who read their work before it reaches the publisher.

Last time in our beta reader series, we talked about a wise general approach to briefing a beta reader. “Treat ‘em mean, keep ‘em keen” may or may not be my default policy with gardening, but I don’t advise it as the best way to approach beta readers! 😉 “Treat them like precious jewels and have a parade in their honour” is closer to the mark.

Let’s look at some tips for the logistical side of your briefing.

Logistics specifics (trying saying that five times fast)

I find it’s wise to be as specific as you can about practical details. (I’ve learned this the hard way, of course. 😉 ) You’ll be surprised how much we all pussyfoot around, afraid to be pushy or too directive, trying not to offend anyone… and then the exact opposite happens, and everyone ends up confused or frustrated or resentful, because of assumptions and lack of information! Aagh!

No one likes a bossy author, but the trick is to communicate. Ask them what they want, but let them know what you want as well, as it may turn out to suit them just fine, if only you’d asked.

If you are both new at this and neither of you really know what you want, that’s fine too. I usually find that just being honest and transparent with people gets much better results! There’s no shame whatsoever in newbies muddling through together — great friendships are often built that way. Even “old hands” can enjoy muddling through together.

Here are some specific practical details that you might discuss.

Timing

  • When do you actually need their report? Think about it in the context of your overall schedule, don’t just pluck a date from the air. Then talk to them about how they are placed. Is a quick turnaround possible, or do they need more time? If you really do need it in a hurry, and they’re busy, perhaps they have time to do a quick read and “instinctive” response, without going into too much depth? Modify your request to suit their availability.
  • Do you have a publishing deadline or a competition to enter? If so, how much time will you need to rework your manuscript in light of the beta reader’s comments and suggestions? Work back from the deadline date to figure out how much time you can allow the beta reader. I usually aim to allow six weeks for my changes AFTER the report, and six weeks for the beta reader to read and make their comments, which means giving it to them 12 weeks before deadline… but it’s not always possible. (If that sounds like a long time, maybe you and your betas are turbocharged and very fleet of foot, but bear in mind that I find MANY people underestimate how long it will take, and end up with a rushed rewrite that doesn’t do justice to the potential of their book. Just sayin’.)
  • It’s often a good idea to set a timeframe, even if you don’t have an external deadline to meet. People who are given forever to get a job done will usually take, oh, round about that long. 😉 But don’t be bonkers about it. If you say, “I need it by next Wednesday,” and then you don’t publish it till 2042, and they’ve stayed home from work and neglected their children to get it done for you, it’s probably not going to create a sweet working relationship for the future!

Format to GIVE to them

Everyone has preferences for how they’d rather read. As we talked about in the general approach, do your best to provide a format they prefer. Communicate.

  • Word doc? If you don’t have Word, you can usually create a readable file from Open Office, and you can even export to Word from Scrivener.
  • A format for their e-reader? It’s surprisingly easy to create an ebook in a hurry using either Word + Calibre, or Scrivener.
  • A printout? Some people still prefer this, so if that’s what they want, provide it if you can… but don’t be afraid to negotiate if printing and postage is too expensive for you.
  • Something else I haven’t thought of? Talk to them about it.

Format to RECEIVE from them

For a simple, easy-to-read explanation of ways to use writing feedback, check out my info page for Use the Power of Feedback to Write a Better Book

When it comes to receiving their feedback…

  • The first thing to consider is: How would THEY like to give their comments?? If you possibly can, let them do it the way they find easiest. But again, negotiate if there are problems for you.
  • Would you prefer a separate text file, which they write up in Word or some other word processor?
  • In the body of an email?
  • Would you like them to use the “Track Changes” feature of Word within your actual manuscript?
  • As notations on an ebook file if you’ve produced a .mobi or .epub for them?
  • As written notes on a printout of your manuscript? (Don’t forget to provide the hard copy, or at least reimburse their printing costs, and pay for return postage.) If you’ve got beta readers in other countries, the hard copy might be a bit, well, hard to do. Paper is heavy, and manuscripts can be excruciatingly expensive to post.
  • Again, it’s always good to let them go for the response format the prefer, if you possibly can. But having the discussion now will potentially avert problems later, and may just make your job easier if they’re happy to provide your preferred format.

Next time we’ll look at ways to ask for specific content in your beta report. (Subscribe to the blog using the form below, if you’d like to know when that article lands.)

What’s your experience with beta reader briefings? If you’ve been someone’s beta reader, what did you find useful? What makes it harder?

Featured image via Bigstock/Goodluz

Please share!

  • Tweet
  • Click to email a link to a friend (Opens in new window) Email
  • More
  • Share on Tumblr
  • Click to share on Reddit (Opens in new window) Reddit

Like this:

Like Loading...

Filed Under: Beta Readers, Writing & Editing

About Belinda

Belinda Pollard is an Australian publishing consultant, IPEd accredited editor, podcaster & writing coach. She is also an award-winning author & speaker, who hates housework, but loves wilderness, dogs and chips. Read More…

Subscribe to this blog

Copyright Statement and Acknowledgements

All articles are © Belinda Pollard. You may quote a short excerpt with a link back to this website, but written permission is required for any other usage. Thanks for respecting my hard work! 🙂

Most images are supplied by Bigstock, and are copyright to their various creators. I recommend Bigstock as an economical source of great images.

The design theme of this blog is supplied by Studiopress (News Pro theme on Genesis Framework). I love Studiopress themes and highly recommend them! They look great and are much easier to operate than some themes I’ve tried.

Comments

  1. Soren Summers says

    August 12, 2016 at 5:40 pm

    Belinda, your beta reader series was invaluable when I was puzzling my way through the process. My readers even thanked me for providing a questionnaire, something I never would have considered before you mentioned it. Thank you for laying out all this advice so clearly (and generously!).

    A quick, non-beta related question. I’m not sure when you turned off timestamps for your blog. It’s never troubled me as a reader either way, but have you received any feedback on the matter from other visitors? I’m building a backlog of articles for my own blog and have been unable to decide about providing the date of each entry’s publication.

    Reply
    • Belinda Pollard says

      August 12, 2016 at 7:48 pm

      Soren, I’m so glad the beta reader series has been useful. I really am quite a passionate believer in the power of a crack team of beta readers!

      As for the issue of timestamps on the blog, I decided to turn mine off when I knew I couldn’t always blog weekly. My articles are designed to be evergreen, and if there’s a gap between them, they don’t look “stale”. No one has ever said they didn’t like it, although that doesn’t necessarily mean they do like it! It’s become quite a common thing to turn the date field off.

      Best wishes with your books and your blog! 🙂

      Reply
      • Soren Summers says

        August 13, 2016 at 7:08 am

        Wow, thank you for the prompt response! I see what you mean, removing timestamps certainly works in your favor then. My topics are more time-constrained so I suppose I’ll have to leave them up for now.

        Thanks again, Belinda. I look forward to reading more of your great articles… and diving through those evergreen ones as well 😉

        Reply
  2. Jonathan says

    December 21, 2014 at 2:01 am

    Great site. I’ve just been asked to beta read for the first time which is exciting and … scary for the reasons you mention. Has the next article in this series been published yet?

    Have you considered a column for beta readers or do you have a good referral site? Jon

    Reply
    • Belinda Pollard says

      December 27, 2014 at 9:46 pm

      Thanks Jonathan. It’s been a busy few months, so that follow-up article isn’t written yet! However, I’ll put it on my list to do soon. Best wishes for your beta reading adventures. It’s a very valuable thing to do for writers. I’m trying to build a useful resource of articles here, as I definitely believe in the value of good beta readers.

      Reply
      • Jonathan says

        December 29, 2014 at 3:36 am

        My thanks, appreciation and an internet delivered hug for a good New Year. Jon

        Reply
  3. Marianne Wheelaghan (@MWheelaghan) says

    April 24, 2014 at 5:32 am

    Brilliant advice, which I am going to find very helpful in the not too distant future – I hope ;~)
    I especially love your advice to “Treat them like precious jewels and have a parade in their honour”!
    Thanks. Look forward to the next post in the series.

    Oops – nearly forgot: the biggest shock I had with using beta readers was not so much what they said as how long it took some of them to say it. So, I agree, setting a time framework to work within for your beat readers is a very good idea – and 12 weeks sounds realistic, even optimistic! Thanks again 🙂

    Reply
    • Belinda Pollard says

      April 24, 2014 at 9:19 pm

      I know what you mean, Marianne. I’m hoping to be able to follow some of my own advice soon too! Gotta finish that manuscript first… 😉

      I’ve had some superstar beta readers get back to me in a weekend in the past when I had a tight deadline (bless them) but I do think much longer timeframes are more reasonable. Thanks for stopping by. 🙂

      Reply
  4. MM Jaye says

    April 22, 2014 at 12:39 am

    Thankfully, my beta reading experience so far has been nothing but positive! The authors I’ve worked with I consider friends, and they’ve been very accommodating especially where the time frame was concerned, but also in terms of the format of the document they sent over. On my part, I asked them how they’d prefer to get my feedback (gradually or through a full beta report in the end) and I also made sure that all the points I raise are backed with arguments that–at least to me–appear solid. I’ve also been lucky in terms of feeling “pampered” afterwards. I was showered with thanks, even made the Acknowledgment page in a couple of instances. That was a lot more than I’d bargained for! So all in all, I find beta reading an extremely fulfilling experience, that also helps me evolve both as a writer and in terms of offering support.

    Reply
    • Belinda Pollard says

      April 22, 2014 at 8:30 am

      Good tip, Maria. Sometimes it’s useful to have progressive feedback, for a variety of reasons. Glad you’ve had such a positive experience.

      Reply

Trackbacks

  1. It is finished! Sort of. Beta Readers Wanted, Inquire within. | JasonAnspach.com says:
    May 19, 2015 at 6:36 am

    […] What is a beta reader?  Consider them constructive critics, also called “the superheroes self-publishing.” […]

    Reply
  2. Unmasking our Beta Reader Superheroes | David Bruns says:
    December 18, 2014 at 1:43 am

    […] post, we explained what beta readers are and why we think they’re superheroes. (Thanks again, Belinda Pollard!) Now it’s time to explain who they are and why we think we have the best early reader team any […]

    Reply
  3. Two Navy Guys Talk About Planning for Beta Readers | David Bruns says:
    November 5, 2014 at 8:29 am

    […] of today’s post is beta readers. According to editor and writer Belinda Pollard, they are the “superheroes of self-publishing,” and I agree wholeheartedly. As we explained early on, one of our goals in writing this book was to […]

    Reply
  4. What Is A Beta Reader And Why Do I Need One? | @Belinda_Pollard says:
    June 30, 2014 at 2:04 pm

    […] Briefing a Beta Reader: Practical details […]

    Reply
  5. April 21 | Larry Crane says:
    April 25, 2014 at 1:07 pm

    […] Briefing a Beta Reader: Practical details […]

    Reply

Leave a Reply Cancel reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Subscribe by email

Finger pointing "here" with words: subscribe to this blog

Check out my Strengthen Your Book series of courses

A pink typewriter on an aqua background with the words Strengthen Your Book

Follow Me Online

  • Amazon
  • Facebook
  • Instagram
  • LinkedIn
  • Twitter
  • YouTube

Browse my library of articles

 

I use and recommend

AWeber Free: Email marketing for free. No credit card required.
Alliance of Independent Authors /
Web Hosting
IPPY Silver Medalist 2015
The Book Designer
Pixel of Ink

ECDA-GoldStar-Dec-2014

MENU

  • Home
  • About
  • START HERE
  • Hire Us
  • Book Coaching
  • Books
  • Speaking
  • Contact
  • Subscribe

TOPICS

  • Writing Tips
  • Write Your Life
  • Feedback & Revision
  • Self-Publishing
  • Book Marketing

A personal note…

I hope you find this site useful. It’s a business and my livelihood, so please assume most links are affiliate links, where I receive a small percentage if you end up buying a product – but it doesn’t cost you any extra. I only recommend tools and resources that I use myself, and which I think might help you. Honesty is a key value here!

Privacy policy

Read my privacy policy here.

Terms & Conditions

Read our Social Media Terms here.

Read our Website Terms of Use here.

Small Blue Dog Publishing

PO Box 310,
Lawnton, Queensland, 4501
Australia

Thank you for visiting!

I hope to see you again soon. ~ Belinda

Copyright © 2025 · News Pro Theme On Genesis Framework · WordPress · Log in

%d